A national boiler replacement scheme would be over five times more effective in reducing carbon emissions from domestic heating than the government’s flagging domestic Renewable Heat Incentive (RHI) and should be introduced as a priority by the Department of Energy and Climate Change (DECC), says OFTEC.
Independently verified data (see table*) released today by OFTEC compares the benefits of converting households with a standard efficiency oil boiler to either:
- a renewable heat technology part-funded by the RHI, or
- a new high efficiency condensing oil boiler.
The figures show it costs the taxpayer c. £5,000 in RHI repayments to incentivise the installation of an air source heat pump (the cheapest technology under the RHI) in an average three bedroom semi-detached property, based on a seven year payback period. In this scenario, the homeowner has to find around £7,000 up-front to fund the installation; their average annual heating bill would increase by £564 to £1,453 p.a. and carbon emissions would be reduced by 3.49 tonnes per annum.
For the same £5,000 funding spent on one household, the government could help 12 households upgrade their old inefficient boilers via a £400 cashback boiler replacement programme - similar to the one introduced by Boris Johnson MP mayor of London in February.
The upfront cost to each consumer would be c. £1,600 (a new boiler costs c. £2k), while the average annual fuel bill for each oil heated home would fall by £158 to just £731 (based on the current average annual price of heating oil).
More importantly, the collective carbon savings for all 12 homes would be 19.56 tonnes every year, compared to just 3.49 tonnes for the single air source heat pump home – a 560% improvement in carbon reduction.
Jeremy Hawksley, director general of OFTEC, the Oil Firing Technical Association, explains: “It’s difficult to ignore the compelling argument for a national boiler replacement scheme that our research provides. By continuing to fund the flagging RHI (and ignoring boiler replacement) the Government is forfeiting the chance to save 16.07 tonnes of CO2 p.a. for every £5,000 of expenditure.
“The UK needs carbon reduction and energy efficiency schemes which will make a decisive change. We believe that many home owners would buy into the concept of bringing forward their boiler replacement because it would reduce their heating bills and is good for the environment.
“Unless you are very wealthy, the domestic RHI is unattractive due to the high installation costs of renewable heating technologies like heat pumps; the disruption installation often means for homes (e.g. new large radiators or underfloor heating, improved insulation) and consumers’ energy bills actually increase.
“A simple boiler replacement scheme would be more affordable and easier to implement for homeowners, so take up would be much higher, resulting in a far higher cumulative reduction in carbon emissions.”
OFTEC has written to Lord Bourne of DECC and rural MPs urging them to support the strong case for a universal boiler replacement scheme and has also submitted evidence to the Energy and Climate Change Select Committee’s inquiry ‘2020 renewable heat and transport.
Jeremy Hawksley concludes: “DECC needs to take action now. The poor RHI take up figures to date clearly show the scheme is not working and falling way behind target. New alternatives which actually work are urgently needed and boiler replacement could play a key part.”
BOILER REPLACEMENT AND THE FUEL POOR
Jeremy Hawksley also commented on the fuel poor:
“The recent Panorama programme ‘Too Poor To Stay Warm’** highlighted the plight of those people in the UK living in fuel poverty which could be as many as five million. Research from University College London also shows some 9,000 people died during winter 2014/15 as a direct result of living in cold homes. That’s 20% of the total number of excess winter deaths which in 2016 is unacceptable.
“Government could tackle this by giving additional funding to the Energy Company Obligation (ECO) which is targeted at the fuel poor, and insist on a similar boiler replacement programme in these homes. The DECC fund to help those with no central heating is pitifully small (£25m) and this too could be enhanced to alleviate fuel poverty by providing oil central heating to homes where there is no heating at present.
*The table below compares the benefits of converting one home from a standard efficiency oil boiler to an air source heat pump or biomass boiler through the RHI, or upgrading to a new condensing oil boiler.
Note: figures are based on a typical three bedroomed semi-detached home with an annual heat and hot water requirement of 16,000kWh.
** BBC1’s Panorama programme ‘Too Poor To Stay Warm’ aired on Monday 21 March. Watch again here.
Source: OFTEC 20TH April, 2016